KMS vs Parameter Store vs Secrets Manager : Details Comparison

CloudDeepDive
5 min readMar 22, 2023
Logo

As more and more organizations move towards cloud computing, there has been a significant shift towards managing secrets and sensitive data. AWS offers several services to handle such scenarios, including AWS Key Management Service (KMS), AWS Systems Manager Parameter Store, and AWS Secrets Manager.

In this blog, we will explore the differences between these three services and their use cases.

AWS Key Management Service (KMS)

AWS KMS is a fully managed service that allows you to create and control encryption keys to protect your data. It is a central service for managing cryptographic keys and controlling their use across a wide range of AWS services and in your own applications. KMS allows you to generate, store, and manage encryption keys that are used to encrypt and decrypt your data.

Key Management Service

Some key features of AWS KMS include:

  • Secure and scalable key management: AWS KMS provides a highly available and scalable service for managing encryption keys.
  • Integration with AWS services: KMS integrates with many AWS services, such as Amazon S3, EBS, RDS, and Lambda, making it easy to encrypt and decrypt data.
  • Customer-managed and AWS-managed keys: You can choose to use your own keys or use keys provided by AWS.
  • Easy key rotation: AWS KMS makes it easy to rotate keys and ensure that they are up-to-date.

AWS KMS is a great service for encryption and decryption of data, but it is not suitable for storing secrets or sensitive data like passwords or API keys.

AWS Systems Manager Parameter Store

AWS Systems Manager Parameter Store is a managed service that provides a secure and scalable way to store and manage configuration data, including secrets. Parameter Store is designed to store data that can be in plain text or encrypted.

Paramter Store

Some key features of AWS Systems Manager Parameter Store include:

  • Centralized configuration management: Parameter Store allows you to store parameters in a hierarchical structure, making it easy to organize and manage your data.
  • Versioning and history tracking: You can store and track changes to parameters over time, making it easy to roll back to previous versions if necessary.
  • Integration with AWS services: Parameter Store integrates with many AWS services, making it easy to retrieve configuration data directly from your applications.
  • Cost-effective: Parameter Store is a cost-effective way to manage configuration data.

While Parameter Store is a great option for storing configuration data, it is not designed for storing large amounts of data, and it doesn’t provide the same level of access controls as Secrets Manager.

AWS Secrets Manager

AWS Secrets Manager is a managed service that allows you to store and manage secrets like passwords, database credentials, and API keys. Secrets Manager is designed to store and manage secrets securely, and it provides a scalable and highly available solution for managing secrets.

Secrets Manager

Some key features of AWS Secrets Manager include:

  • Secure storage and management of secrets: Secrets Manager stores secrets securely and provides fine-grained access controls to manage who can access them.
  • Automatic secret rotation: Secrets Manager can automatically rotate secrets on a schedule, making it easy to comply with security best practices and regulations.
  • Integration with AWS services: Secrets Manager integrates with many AWS services, making it easy to retrieve secrets directly from your applications.
  • Auditing and compliance: Secrets Manager provides audit logs and integrates with AWS CloudTrail for compliance reporting.

Secrets Manager is a great option for storing and managing secrets, but it may not be the best fit for storing large amounts of data or configuration data. It also has higher costs compared to Parameter Store.

Key differences between KMS, Parameter Store, and Secrets Manager

The following table summarizes the key differences between AWS KMS, Parameter Store, and Secrets Manager:

Key Differences

In addition to the differences already mentioned, Parameter Store supports both plaintext and encrypted data, allowing you to choose the level of security appropriate for your use case. Meanwhile, Secrets Manager provides more fine-grained access controls than Parameter Store, including secret policy-based permissions, allowing you to manage who can access your secrets at a granular level.

Finally, all three services support plaintext and encrypted data, but Secrets Manager and Parameter Store are optimized for managing secrets and configuration data respectively.

Conclusion

In conclusion, AWS KMS, Parameter Store, and Secrets Manager are three different services that provide different solutions for managing secrets and sensitive data. KMS is great for encryption and decryption of data, while Parameter Store is ideal for storing configuration data. Secrets Manager is designed for storing and managing secrets like passwords and API keys.

Choosing the right service for your use case is essential, and you should consider factors like the type of data you want to store, the level of security you need, and the integration with other AWS services.

In general, if you need to store sensitive data like passwords or API keys, Secrets Manager is the best choice. If you need to store configuration data, Parameter Store is a good option. If you need to encrypt and decrypt data, KMS is the right service for you.

It’s also important to note that these services can be used together to provide a more comprehensive solution. For example, you can use KMS to encrypt data and store the encryption keys in Secrets Manager.

By understanding the differences between these services and their use cases, you can choose the right service for your needs and ensure that your data is secure and well-managed.

Hope! you have found this blog informative & useful and if so please 👏, share and also subscribe to our “CloudDeepDive” space for more wonderful content.

--

--

CloudDeepDive

Hey Folks! Let's Deep Dive the clouds 🌨️ with me. In this journey we will discover hidden treasures of cloud together. #Cloud #DevOps #CloudComputing